The Spartans
|
List Price: Our Price: $9.23 You Save: $10.76 (54%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $9.20 (click here) Category: DVD See more DVD releases |
|---|
Buy this DVD movie at online store in your country
Canada
Canada
Movie Reviews of The Spartans
Movie Review: Should be named the History of the Greece
Summary: 4 Stars
I expected this DVD to be about Sparta, but it dealt with the whole Greek civilization when Sparta was at its peak. It was three different programs; each an hour in length. An excellent review of Greece and their individual thought concepts regarding public life, sex, treatment of women, slaves and war. Well worth watching, but I did not add it to my personal DVD library.Movie Review: Sips of Lethe, apologies to Clio
Summary: 3 Stars
If anything, this presentation of the Spartans has reinforced my understanding of brain research which finds that memory is synthetic, and, while certain facts are undeniable due to the mass of evidence, we create much of what we consider factual. Some documentaries are up-front about being personal views, and this one would benefit by such a cautionary preface. To inaccuracies mentioned by other reviewers I would add two lapses in well-known textual sources regarding the Spartans and the Peloponnesian War: the comment about a wail of grief passing along the great walls from the port to the city of Athens after the military disaster in Syracuse has been transposed from Xenophon's report in the Hellenica (2.2.3) which mentions this very demonstration of grief after the final defeat of the Athenians at Aegospotami. Following that ultimate defeat, Ms. Hughes mentions -- complete with flames in the foreground -- the burning down of the great walls to the accompaniment of the music of flute-girls. The word Xenophon uses is "kateskapton," which means "demolish, raze to the ground" -- no fire involved. They were, after all, stone walls. Xenophon was a 26 year-old and in Athens at the time of these events, so it seems likely that he was giving true reports. Less serious, but nevertheless confusing, is the reference to the Delphic oracle while at the temple of Athena Pronaia. (Would it not be more appropriate to be at the temple of Apollo for this, where the Oracle was actually given? It is just up the hill from the Tholos.)
I was looking for a fresh and accurate presentation of the Spartans to show to my class as a counterweight to 300 -- which they are all clamoring for me to show. I will probably use this DVD in conjunction with several corrections and words of caution. I have already used Ms. Hughes' DVD Athens: The Dawn of Democracy and found it quite helpful in dispelling the romantic notions we have come to accept regarding Athens and democracy. We would do well to keep in mind that a good part of the world regards our American democracy as imperialistic, like democratic Athens.
Movie Review: A Disappointment
Summary: 2 Stars
Although drawing on the advice of expert Paul Cartelege and producing an excellent visual experience with beautiful on location sequences, the entire documentary is disappointing rehash of the usual clichés about Sparta. The image of Sparta is uni-dimensional, some quotes from Herodotus taken out of context, and the picture of Sparta undifferentiated. For example, there is no evidence whatever that, as suggested in the film, the boys of the agoge lived outside of society for more than a few months, much less that they learned no skills other than survival and fighting. Spartan men were literate, admired for their wit, their terse rhetoric and were skilled in music and dance. The insistance on "compulsory homosexuality" and the image of a society in which men and women led completely separate lives is controversial at best and ridiculous at worst. The focus on Sparta's hoplites alone, while traditional, nevertheless distorts the fact that even Spartan men were only on active service for 10 years and men over the age of 30 no longer had to live in barracks. In fact, they lived on their farms with their wives and children like gentlemen farmers everywhere in the world. Likewise the recurring theme of the oppressed Messenians overlooks the fact that Sparta apparently had very loyal Laconian helots. It is a pity that such a good opportunity for a more balanced view of Sparta was missed in favour of the usual unidimensional treatment. For an alternative interpretation of Sparta based on ancient sources rather than modern myth read any of Helena Schrader's novels set in Ancient Sparta:Are They Singing in Sparta?, Spartan Slave, Spartan Queen: A Tale of Four Women in Sparta, or The Olympic CharioteerMovie Review: for intellectual helots only
Summary: 2 Stars
If your idea of a good documentary is having some fairly good-looking chick (for academic standards--let's be real)with a british accent self-consciouly jump around a few ruins wearing colorful blouses and tight jeans, well then, you've found what you're looking for. Otherwise stay away. Apart from a short scene that dealt with Cinadon's conspiracy in 398 BC, there was virtually nothing of interest here. It's pablum.Movie Review: Unsatisfying In Every Way
Summary: 1 Stars
This is NOT good. Three hour-long episodes of this remind one why PBS still has a fundraiser every year. Because shows like this, that could be fascinating, are just boring.
If you've seen or read about the city/state system of Greece, there are many conclusions drawn here that either just don't add up, or seem outright wrong.
The narrator appears on screen constantly, and I'm not sure why. Her tone and facial expression seem to indicate a distaste for the material, prompting one to ask why she did this in the first place. Or felt the need to be onscreen non-stop. It ends up being distracting, to the point that it takes away from the scholarly enterprise that's supposed to be going on. Certainly footage of the Greek countryside could have been used.
Also odd, why they show footage of modern day people in modern pubs while talking about Sparta and Athens of 480 B.C. No money from the sale of totebags to afford a reenactment here or there?
All in all, it makes you trealize how much better the History Channel and Discovery Channel now do the same material.
You'd do better to either watch Zack Snyder's movie, The 300, or read its source material, the Frank Miller graphic novel of the same name. Both play it more than a little loose history-wise, but the battle scenes are spectacular.
Your best bet? See the History Channel's documentary, now on DVD, The Last Stand of the 300. Historically accurate, fantastic reenactments, costumes, and drama. Drama befitting the true tale of the 300.
More Movie Reviews:
1 2
1 2