Movie Reviews for The Golden Compass (Widescreen Single-Disc Edition)

The Golden Compass (Widescreen Single-Disc Edition)

	List Price: ~~$28.98~~ Our Price: $3.88 You Save: $25.10 (87%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $2.86 (click here) Category: DVD See more DVD releases

Buy this DVD movie at online store in your country
Canada

Movie Reviews of The Golden Compass (Widescreen Single-Disc Edition)

Movie Review: disappointment
Summary: 1 Stars

The movie was a disapointment. Yeah, the graphics were ok but not as good. The story line deviates from the book. If you are a fan of the book I recommend not buying this movie. It's ok to watch but not to own. They could have done much more but they didn't. I watched the movie before deciding wether to buy it or not and trust me, its not worth your money.

Movie Review: Couldn't make any sense of it
Summary: 1 Stars

I've got a funny feeling that this was made by massive fans of the book. And they thought that every one else in the world, has read it and where also massive fans of the book. I've never read the book, so maybe if I had the movie might have made some sense.

Movie Review: The book was very good - the movie was disappointing
Summary: 1 Stars

I read the first two books with great enthusiasm, and slowed a bit with the third as it petered out and became preachy.

But I was excited about Golden Compass because it was a well written book and I was interested to see how it was ported to the big screen.

Sadly, it was dumbed-down so much that most of the plot of the book - which was unraveled skillfully in the book - is revealed in the first 5 minutes of the movie through exposition.

You are flat out told that people in this world wear their souls on the outside of their body in the form of familiar animals. In the book you figure it out on your own and feel clever about it when you do so.

This is the case for half the plot of the book. It is just told to you in synopsis form by a narrator and all of the joy of DISCOVERING things is taken from you.

I don't know who the director is, but I intend to find out and avoid his future movies. Hopefully they hire him to finish out the series (doubtful, since this one was dismal at the box office) so he won't ruin any other movies for a while.

In short, if you liked the book - and Golden Compass was a good book, even if you are an intolerant right wing person this book shouldn't have offended you, they don't start really offending the Catholics until book three in my opinion - then you will be disappointed by the movie. It was just poorly done.

A final note, yes - the special effects and cinematography were good, but any idiot with some money can hire good computer graphic companies and do that these days. It was the story that was ruined by this shoddy directing.

Movie Review: Good entertainment
Summary: 4 Stars

I thought this was a very good movie. Don't know what all the religious uproar was about. Remember this is a Fantasy Movie. Hope the bad press doesn't stop them from making the other parts to the story.