Otello (1986)
|
Our Price: $35.69 Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Used: from $24.94 (click here) Category: DVD See more DVD releases |
|---|
Canada
Movie Reviews of Otello (1986)
Movie Review: Great or Horrible?
Summary: 2 Stars
Well, to start, I am huge fan of Otello, Domingo and Zeffirelli. But somehow I was disappointed (sometimes a lot!) with this movie. Before I bought the DVD I had read some reviews, and most reviewers were chocked by the cuts in the score and I always thought: big deal. But when I watched it I understood: THERE IS ABOUT 25 min OF CUTS!!! Most of Otellos (Levine's, Karajan's, Toscanini's) are about 2h15. This one is 1h55 with over 10 min of music and ballet that Verdi never wrote (You do the math, and remember that Maazel's tempi are much slower than Toscanini's). Also, not only are these cuts of arias or ensembles, but even worse: Phrases are just cut off here and there throughout the Opera. The 1000 words allowed for the review won't be enough to enumerate them. Why??? A reviewer argued that it's to enhance the drama!! Come on, are you going to convince me that the finale of Act II (Si, pel Ciel) needs enhancement. Even this part is cut, and worse it's "Cut IN HALF AND I MEAN IN HALF" as another reviewer pointed.
So what does go right?
Well the scenary is amazing and I mean amazing. But what about the performance (this is Opera after all). Well again much can be said. Domingo once said that his performance was very much influenced by Zeffirelli. He wanted him to go into some deep barytonal voice (à la Ramon Vinay of you will), and the performance suffers.
Maazel conducting is far from being ideal. Should he be blamed? Well yes, like most of the singers who agreed to represent Zeffirelli's Otello and not Verdi's.
Finally, one of the reviewer said that Zeffirelli tried to "adapt" the opera and those who dislike is are not open-minded. Oh Please! When you buy Verdi's Otello, you are expecting to hear some of the most beautiful music ever written adapted to one of the most successfull libretto and won't expect the director to cut off about 25 min of the score.
It is normal to be disappointed. With a cast like this one and a director like Zeffirelli (his Traviata, Cav. Rusticana, and Traviata are awesome) we could have had the most successful opera movie Ever....
Finally, I need to point out that one who doesn't know Otello "as is" could be thrilled with this version. It is after all a real beautiful movie.
Movie Review: The film has been transferred at the wrong speed
Summary: 1 Stars
As soon as I started playing the DVD I knew that something was terribly wrong. A quick comparison with my CD set of the soundtrack, and other recordings of 'Otello', confirmed my fear: the film has been transferred at a slower frame rate than was originally intended, and thus everything sounds lower than the correct pitch.MGM DVD gets zero stars for an unforgivable error.
Movie Review: FZ what an EGO
Summary: 1 Stars
If Zef needs to eliminate "The Willow Song" and parts of the Love Duet he does a disservice to the opera and I will not spend money on this video.