Malena
|
List Price: Our Price: $9.99 You Save: $23.00 (70%) Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Used: from $4.50 (click here) Category: DVD See more DVD releases |
|---|
Buy this DVD movie at online store in your country
Canada
Canada
Movie Reviews of Malena
Movie Review: How could it be (so bad)?
Summary: 1 Stars
How could it be so bad?
It has, after all, all the required ingredients : the setting of Fascist Italy, Monica Belucci, a boy entering puberty, lust, voyeurism, small-town gossip, jealousy, rape - and to top it all, the failsafe foreign-film label complete with subtitles. How could it fail?
But make no mistake; this is a poor, poor film. It has to be, if even the considerable charms of signora Belluci eventually not only fail to hold the interest, but, unbelievably, start to irritate. It is so overstated, espescially in the cartoonish, stereotypical overreaction of the men of the town (when she passes by) that it repelled me. One can still make allowance for the clich? of the macho Italian man, but not for the course, offensive chauvinism which we are expected to believe all the townsmen wallow in without reservation. It eventually amounts to little more than an insult to Italian men in general and, more pertinently, the viewer's intelligence.
Add to this the fact that the film borrows heavily, and poorly from the standards of the foreign-film diet (Cinema Paradiso, from the same director, immediately comes to mind) and you have, in a nutshell, all the reasons to avoid this flop.
Louis M
Movie Review: Charming "Coming of Age" film...
Summary: 5 Stars
There are a lot of reasons I enjoyed "Malena". The world seen through the eyes of children is always a good thing, if only to take us back to when things were simple and centered. Add to this idea the idea of war, bullies, and the meanness of the townspeople (read: ignorance), I enjoyed the film a lot. There were a few slow moments, but the ascent to manhood has seldom been displayed more sweetly or sensitively. Worth a look. Movie Review: VERY BEAUTIFUL...and a great story from War times.
Summary: 5 Stars
I truly enjoyed this movie. Monica Bellucci is not only beautiful as Malena but to watch her silent beauty, and the young man who admires her from afar and who becomes her shadow is refreshing. The story of life in a small town for this woman whose only sin was to be beautiful, shows how tragic gosip and innuendo can be. Movie Review: A good movie (mild spoiler inside)
Summary: 4 Stars
I found this movie to be an enjoyable, fairly original coming-of-age story.
I liked that fact that the character's growth does not follow the usual, Hollywood-style format, where a male adolescent becomes a man by overcoming his own difficulties. Rather, here Renato grows by observing Malena from afar (literally or figuratively), and by understanding everything that the archaic and malevolent rest of the local population does not want and cannot grasp. I also liked the bitter-sweet ending (more bitter than sweet) and the very very sweet moment which will represent the first and last direct interaction between Renato and Malena.
At the same time, acting is a bit uneven, the pace and soundtrack a bit too close to those in Nuovo Cinema Paradiso, and there a bit too many caricatures ("macchiette", one could say in Italian) and forcedly silly moments interspersed across the movie. Overall, though, it's been definitely worth watching.
Last but not least, Ms Bellucci, while not outstanding in her acting, shows once again to be otherworldly beautiful. I cannot think of many women in movie history with such a moving beauty (with the exception maybe of Claudia Cardinale).
Movie Review: Una fimmina bedda faces provincial prejudice
Summary: 4 Stars
Giuseppe Tornatore's "Malena" (2000)is a moving, nicely put together portrait of small-town narrowmindedness. Set in Sicily during World War II, it follows the misfortunes faced by a beautiful young woman whose soldier husband is presumed dead. The lovely Monica Bellucci plays the silent, voluptuous Malena whose face and figure raise havoc in the minds (and bodies) of virtually every man in town. Among her ardent admirers is 12 year old Renato (well portrayed by Giuseppe Sulfaro), who spies on her by day and enthusiastically fantasizes about her by night. The lust of the local men and envy of the townswomen eventually lead to Malena's ostracism, and when her penniless situation forces her into prostitution the women take violent action against her. When Malena's husband unexpectedly surfaces, it is young Renato who helps put an end to her pitiful plight.
Although the action takes place in a Sicilian coastal town, one can imagine similar circumstances occuring in many a small, insular community, in nearly every part of the world. Skillful actors (La Bellucci says little, but her performance is soulful) and effective cinematography create a realistic depiction of life in a southern Italian town of the 1940s. One gripe on the part of this viewer: the version of "Malena" released in the United States was cut to remove scenes of nudity, most notably a scene in which Renato has a "vision" of a (fully frontal) nude Malena. What stupidity on the part of American censors! Are we really so puritanical that we cannot face the succinctly sexual nature of most young boys' fantasies?