Divided We Fall
|
List Price: Our Price: $6.99 You Save: $17.97 (72%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $3.80 (click here) Category: DVD See more DVD releases |
|---|
Buy this DVD movie at online store in your country
Canada
Canada
Movie Reviews of Divided We Fall
Movie Review: Birth and Resurrection
Summary: 5 Stars
I have never seen a Czech film I didn't like. This one is top drawer. A childless couple hide a Jew during WW II and the compelling aftermath. The ending is poetically just and symbolic. A must-see.Movie Review: Divided We Fall
Summary: 5 Stars
Marvelous-I have never seen anything like this on the Holocaust. Human, warm, funny---wonderful presentation of people caught in this larger than life series of events.Movie Review: we must help each other-divided we fall
Summary: 5 Stars
definitly recomend this movie to those, who likes dramas.Movie Review: A compelling nuanced story
Summary: 4 Stars
This film isn't going to be like the WWII/Shoah film the average person expects. Instead of focusing on a lot of atrocities and tragedies, almost all of the focus is all on the one couple, Josef and Maria, their Jewish friend David (whose father was Josef's old boss), and Josef and Maria's collaborator friend Horst. The first five minutes of the film give us very short vignettes from 1937, 1939, and 1941, and are pretty much useless, since we're never told who these people are and what their relationship is, apart from giving the viewer an idea of how life changed from the prewar era to after the Nazi occupation of Czechoslovakia. The real meat of the story begins in 1943, when Josef and Maria agree to take in their old friend David, who has escaped from Poland after being interned in Terezin, the sole survivor of his family (the people we saw very brief glimpses of in 1939 and 1941). He came back to the old neighborhood because it's what he knows, and figured, perhaps naďvely, that surely there would be someone who would help him. At great personal risk to themselves, his old friends agree to hide him in a closet in their apartment. This is no easy matter in wartime or under occupation, not least of all because one of Josef's best friends, Horst, is of German descent and therefore profitting greatly now that his people are the ones in power. In addition to Horst's frequent unannounced (and often unwanted) visits and attempts to bed Maria, they also must deal with Horst's boss, a German commandant whom Josef also later agrees to go to work for (prior to that he'd been sleeping through the war and not working). One never knows what is going to happen next, if they'll be turned in by Horst, who suspects or outright knows their secret, if their secret will be discovered by their Czech neighbors or the German occupiers whom Josef has to pretend to be buddy-buddy with to survive, or what anyone's fate might be after the liberation arrives. There are also many fine moments of comedy, none of it forced or overdone.
The film works because the characters are so nuanced and complex. Instead of relying on clichés and one-dimensional stereotypes, the characters are multi-faceted people, with both positive and negative attributes. Horst, the German sympathiser, may be a vulgar boor and a collaborator, but his actions demonstrate that he also possesses humanity, kindness, and loyalty. His boss Dr. Kepke might be a high-ranking Nazi, but he's also shown as a father who loves and cares about his sons, someone with normal human feelings behind the uniform. Even Josef and Maria aren't shown as complete saints just because they've agreed to hide David. They have normal human weaknesses and have the typical problems couples do, in their case particularly because they're still childless after many years of marriage in spite of Maria's fervent prayers to the Virgin Mary to grant them a child. Even the victorious liberators from the Soviet Army, the Czech Home Army, and the Czech partisans aren't depicted as completely understanding and benevolent people just because they're on the winning side. These are people who do what they had to survive, even if some of those things went against everything they had believed in before the war. And in spite of the potential for it given the storyline, the film is never emotionally manipulative or morally heavy-handed. The final scene of the film in particular is very moving. This is one foreign film and historical drama that deserves to be better-known.
Movie Review: Turning your back on a people, be they Jews, Czechs (as Britain & France did), or any people, only delays evil turning on you.
Summary: 4 Stars
"Throughout time, whenever tyrants arose and preached a mixture of world domination and complete intolerance for most other human beings, their first targets were often a small group of people noted for giving the world monotheism, the bible and a set of basic laws that have been followed for thousands of years." "[T]yrannical regimes always seem to have one common link---their deep hatred for Jews." The words are from a Warren Kozak opinion piece (which appeared in the New York Sun August 21, 2006). It's hardly a new idea, of course, yet most of the world still seems disinclined to acknowledge it. Blatant anti-Semitism is thus not just something for Jews to worry about. All folks who champion freedom thus, in effect, ought see themselves as part Jewish themselves: either you stand with the persecuted or you are just putting off the day when you might just as likely be faced with similar persecution. That's the central point of "Divided We Fall"---"the true and bittersweet story of a Czechoslovakian couple whose village has been taken over by Nazis during World War II." When a Jewish friend escapes from German confinement and makes his way back to their common neighborhood, the couple has a choice to make. "I lived here all my life," says the man on the run in the film, "so I thought maybe someone here might help me." But what makes this film unique is the notion that non-Jews really need to wed Jews (metaphorically) to stand up against anti-Semitism; for, without a union of some sorts, they are looking for trouble to come their way eventually. How the film presents this point is most unusual, but I won't get into specifics here, not wishing to give away crucial plot details. Suffice it say that the film exaggerates the above to make its point very clearly and does so with much style and accomplishment. That it's a Czech-made story only reinforces the idea that if you sacrifice a people (as Britain & France did) it's only going to temporarily put off the day of your own reckoning with the evil at hand. Nominated for an Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film of 2000 this picture is well worth watching. (06Aug) Cheers!