Movie Reviews for Captain From Castile

Captain From Castile

Captain From Castile List Price: $13.31
Our Price: $13.27
You Save: $6.67 (33%)
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Buy Used: from $9.33 (click here)
Category: DVD
See more DVD releases


(Click here)
Buy this DVD movie at online store in your country
Canada

Movie Reviews of Captain From Castile

Movie Review: Great Movie!!
Summary: 4 Stars

I've always liked this movie as it has a excellent music sound track. Being able to get it on DVD just made it better. The only draw back was the soundtrack wasn't in stereo which was a bit of a disappointment.

Movie Review: does not follow the conclusion of the book.
Summary: 4 Stars

This is a very good movie but it leaves off the conquest of the Aztecs and the return to Spain as it is written in the book. Its a shame that 20th Centry Fox doesn't follow the book.

Movie Review: Two-thirds of a great movie
Summary: 3 Stars

Following exiled Spaniard Tyrone Power's adventures with Cortez and the Conquistadores in the New World after a jealous rival reports his family to the Inquisition and tortures his young sister to death, Captain From Castile is one of those deceptively lavish swashbucklers that promise more than it ever delivers. Despite a 141-minute running time, a huge budget, a good cast, great locations and one of the greatest scores ever written for any movie, it still feels like it's only just getting started when it suddenly ends - which it is, since the spectacular last half of Samuel Shellabarger's doorstop novel never made the screenplay, let alone the cameras. Yet even without that knowledge, the final sequence feels more like a rousing sequence to lead into an intermission and leave the audience hungry for more rather than a satisfying grand finale in itself. After such a buildup, ending the story before Cortez gets to meet Moctezuma, let alone steals and destroys his kingdom, is a terrible anticlimax, especially since the novel goes on to paint his battles in particularly vivid strokes. It's as if William Wyler decided to end Ben-Hur with his hero thinking it might be an idea to challenge his mortal enemy to a chariot race some day or ending a film about the Titanic long before the iceberg is even sighted.

Rather than sensitivity for the Aztec culture he destroyed, the reason seems to be more dictated more by finances than conscience: having spent a reputed $4.8m on a difficult Mexican shoot in many of the then still fairly inaccessible locations Cortez marched through, spending another $4m wasn't an attractive prospect, especially since both the censors and the Catholic Legion of Decency had made clear they found huge sections of the book unacceptable, necessitating heavy rewrites before it could go into production. As it was, the film failed to recoup its cost, though a more satisfying ending might have improved matters a bit.

Yet as much as the film disappoints on a first viewing, a second time around it's easier to see its strengths and enjoy it as a lavishly produced period melodrama. True, it misses the irony of the hero's road from vengeance to spiritual redemption being found on a purely mercenary quest for riches, but Cesar Romero's Cortez is never presented as anything other than a jovial pirate, pure and simple: the more the Aztecs try to bribe him to go home, the more he gleefully realizes they have to steal if he carries on. The Technicolor photography is certainly handsome and the location work pays off (even providing a real volcanic eruption in the background of the final scene to match one that happened during Cortez' march) even if most of the movie is just a long walk through Mexico with more intrigue than action. Best of all is Alfred Newman's incredible score and its rousing Conquest theme, truly music to conquer the world to that's so stirring that you'll want to give up the day job and conquer a third world country and enslave its population yourself.

The Region 1 NTSC disc has a glorious color transfer with a good selection of extras - audio commentary, featurette on Tyrone Power's Leading Ladies, stills and advertising gallery, original theatrical trailer and an isolated score track for Alfred Newman's superb score.

Movie Review: The music is the star
Summary: 3 Stars

I bought this DVD for one reason: the beautiful musical score by Alfred Newman. It also has another asset: the gorgeous cinematography. I was entranced by the music when I saw it many years ago, and looked forward to the DVD. It was a long time coming, possibly because the story (about the looting of Montezuma's treasures by Cortez) was considered politically incorrect. For whatever reason, I'm glad it's finally available. The movie is pretty good in itself, and Jean Peters and Tyrone Power are pretty as well.

Movie Review: Not Enough Real History
Summary: 3 Stars

The conquest of Mexico is one of the great adventure stories in history. This film trivializes it by focusing on the story of one Spanish nobleman (Tyrone Power) and by treating only the beginning of Cortes' campaign. Cesar Romero makes the film in the role of Cortes. He is energetic and magnetic. It's a great performance. The rest of the film pales in comparison. Some will resent the heroic treatment of the conquest, and those who do probably shouldn't see this movie.
More Movie Reviews:
1 2 3 4 5
Compare prices and read customer reviews for more than one million DVD titles.
Oscar 2005 Winners